Have you ever wondered how one city — Istanbul — can produce almost as much wealth as an entire country like Pakistan? It sounds unbelievable, but the numbers tell a clear story. In 2024, Turkey’s GDP stood at around $1.32 trillion, and Istanbul alone contributed about 30% of it — roughly $400 billion. Meanwhile, Pakistan’s total GDP hovers around $410 billion.
In other words, one Turkish city equals the economic size of all of Pakistan. This gap didn’t appear overnight — it’s the result of decades of focused planning, industrialization, and policy consistency. Let’s explore why this gap exists and what Pakistan can learn from Turkey and China’s rapid growth models.
1. What the Numbers Tell Us
Istanbul’s economy is an economic powerhouse that rivals entire nations. The city has become the heart of Turkey’s industry, finance, logistics, and tourism sectors. It alone generates nearly one-third of Turkey’s entire GDP. On the other hand, Pakistan’s economy, though larger in population, is far less productive in terms of output per worker and per city.
To put it simply:
- Istanbul’s GDP: ~$400 billion
- Pakistan’s GDP: ~$410 billion
- Turkey’s total GDP: ~$1.32 trillion
The contrast is clear — Istanbul is the beating heart of Turkey’s economy, while Pakistan’s economic activity is more scattered and less efficient.
2. Why Istanbul (and Turkey) Outperform Pakistan
1. Concentrated Urban Productivity
Istanbul benefits from what economists call “agglomeration effects.” When businesses, services, and workers cluster together in a dense urban area, productivity rises sharply. Istanbul has concentrated industries like finance, manufacturing, logistics, and tourism — all of which generate high value-added output.
2. Strong Industrial Base and Export Diversification
Turkey has built a well-diversified industrial base over decades. It exports automobiles, machinery, electronics, textiles, and consumer goods. Pakistan, by contrast, still relies heavily on textiles and agriculture. This lack of diversification limits Pakistan’s export income and slows growth.
3. Better Infrastructure and Investment Climate
Turkey’s major cities enjoy world-class infrastructure — ports, energy grids, transport, and industrial parks. These reduce costs for businesses. Pakistan still struggles with power shortages, poor logistics, and inconsistent policies that discourage long-term investment.
4. Political and Institutional Stability
Despite its political challenges, Turkey has generally maintained a more consistent industrial and economic policy direction. Pakistan’s frequent policy shifts, political instability, and governance challenges create uncertainty for investors.
5. Skilled Workforce and Urban Planning
Istanbul’s workforce is more skilled and better connected to industrial demand. In contrast, Pakistan’s education and training systems are misaligned with modern industry needs, limiting productivity growth.
3. What China Did Right — Lessons for Pakistan
If there’s one global example of rapid economic transformation, it’s China. Within 40 years, China went from being a poor agrarian economy to the world’s manufacturing hub. How? Through a series of deliberate policies Pakistan could adapt:
- Created Special Economic Zones (SEZs): Cities like Shenzhen were built as manufacturing and export zones with investor-friendly rules.
- Invested in Infrastructure: Roads, ports, energy, and digital networks were prioritized to support industry.
- Encouraged Foreign Investment: China invited global companies to set up factories, creating jobs and transferring technology.
- Maintained Macroeconomic Stability: Predictable policies built investor confidence.
- Focused on Skills: Millions of workers were trained in manufacturing, engineering, and trade skills.
4. How Pakistan Can Catch Up
Pakistan doesn’t need to reinvent the wheel — it needs to apply lessons from Turkey and China with focus and consistency. Here’s how:
- Ensure Macroeconomic Stability: Control inflation, maintain a stable currency, and build investor trust.
- Invest in Infrastructure: Reliable electricity, ports, and transport reduce costs and boost productivity.
- Develop Industrial Clusters: Build strong SEZs near major cities like Karachi, Lahore, and Faisalabad.
- Diversify Exports: Move beyond textiles to include engineering goods, IT services, and value-added agriculture.
- Reform Education and Skills Training: Align vocational training with the needs of modern industries.
- Simplify Business Regulations: Cut red tape and make it easier for entrepreneurs to start and grow businesses.
- Engage the Diaspora and FDI: Tap into overseas Pakistanis and foreign investors for industrial projects.
- Focus on Urban Growth: Develop a few key cities as economic engines — just like Istanbul or Shenzhen.
5. The Bottom Line
The comparison between Istanbul and Pakistan is more than just numbers — it’s about structure, vision, and execution. Istanbul’s success is the result of concentrated productivity, export-led growth, and consistent policy direction.
For Pakistan to make meaningful progress, it must prioritize industrialization, invest in education, and adopt a long-term economic vision. The journey won’t be easy, but with the right reforms, Pakistan’s major cities have the potential to become powerful engines of growth — much like Istanbul has long done — and continues to do — for Turkey.
Leave a comment